Kants categorical imperative The debate on blastocysts
False hope
Indeed, in 2007, Dr.Woo Suk Hwang, a South Korean scientist who is credited for cloning the first human embryo through stem cell research, was accused of falsifying data. This accusation was made by Roh Sung-il, who together with Hwang had carried out a study that purported to indicate that they had created stem cells to treat medical conditions of eleven patients, this had raised hopes for new treatments. However, Dr. Hwang had to withdraw the study paper because of grave errors as well as loopholes in the reporting of the scientific achievement (Buzzle.com, 2008).
Unethical
Numerous ethicists as well as scientists also are against stem cell research. Indeed, in statement given out in July 1999, 100 bio-ethicists, scientists as well as legal scholars stated that, they opposed stem cell research on the basis that it was unethical and needless (Buzzle.com, 2008). Some them point out that latest studies indicate that adult stem cell could be more adaptable than it was thought in the past.
Rebuttal
The key benefits that are derived from embryonic stem cells, is that it is possible to propagate stem cells nearly indefinably in the laboratory. At the same time they can be modified in a genetic way and generally, they can be induced so that they differentiate into different desired cell forms. Nonetheless, as noted by Warnock (1984) the widespread application of embryonic stem cells entails the destruction of the human embryo which in turn raises the ethical question.
0 comments:
Post a Comment